COURT MARTIAL OF
LT. CHARLES G. HUNTER, USN
Just at the time
this third expedition against Alvarado was perfected, a little steamer mounting three
guns, and commanded by Lt. Charles G. Hunter, appeared off Vera Cruz. It was on the day of
the surrender of the City and the Castle of San Juan de Ulloa to the American forces. The
Lieutenant commanding reported to Commodore Perry; and received from him orders to proceed
down the Coast -- to report to Capt. Samuel L. Breese -- and to blockade the river
Alvarado.
Off went the little steamer with its small
complement of officers and men, rather sad that day he had arrived at Sacrificios a few
days too late to be sharers in the honors of the bombardment and capture of Vera Cruz and
her Castle. What were the purposes of the Lieutenant commanding in view of his mal-apropos
time of arrival, the writer knows not. But the action of his little command a few days
after, before Alvarado, has certainly made the capture of that place, the standing joke of
the war. And though the Lieutenant seemed to incur the responsibility of disobedience to
orders, the odium of a court martial -- and certain displeasure in certain quarters -- yet
it would seem equally to appear that his countrymen have sustained him in his action, and
his government at home, informally, have approved his course by giving him a new command!
But the serio-comical farce --(perhaps it should be called
without irony, THE DASHING AND GALLANT MOVE of the Lieutenant commanding the
Scourge) -- no doubt surprised the Commander-in-Chief of the Home Squadron and General
John A. Quitman of the shore forces, as much as it did the newspaper readers at the North.
PRELUDE
"The morning after, we were ordered by our Commodore to
proceed to Alvarado, to blockade that port. We got off the harbor about sunset, and began
to fire into the Fort, when it became dark, and a surf being very heavy on the bar, with
indications of a Norther, we were compelled to stand off and on, which we did during the
night. The next morning we stood in nearly shore again, and began firing a second time
into the Fort, when several horsemen were seen coming down the Beach, at full Gallup and
bearing a white flag. We hove to, to see what they wanted, when a boat was seen coming out
of the harbor, bearing a flag of the same kind, and commanded by the Captain of the port,
who invited us to take possession of the town. We stood up to the town and anchored, run
out and pointed the guns, sent two officers with eight men ashore with a summons of
unconditional surrender, with but thirty minutes time for doing it, -- all of which was
acceded to, -- and thus was taken by one little vessel of three guns and a bold Captain,
the town of Alvarado, the bugbear of the Navy.
Hearing that the Mexican General, with four hundred men, had gone
up the river with several vessels, and munitions of war, we immediately pursued him,
capturing on our way out, four schooners, one loaded with powder, &c., which they had
run upon a shoal and scuttled, which we burned; two we brought down to Alvarado, and the
other we let them keep as being worthless. About 2 o'clock in the morning we arrived at
the city of Flacotalpam, fired a gun, and sent three officers with six men to summon the
Alcalde to surrender. "After the surrender of this place, which is a very pretty
town, containing some seven thousand inhabitants, we returned to Alvarado, getting there
about sunset. That night the Captain took Passed-Midshipman Temple and myself in his boat
and went up the river to assist the bringing down of the prize-schooners. On our way up we
saw a large boat which we ran aboard and captured, and founder to contain ninety bales of
cotton, with a quantity of dry goods and hides, worth three or four thousand dollars.
Flacotalpam is about six or seven leagues up the river of the
same name -- the river is the most beautiful that I ever saw. In some places the banks are
one hundred feet high, covered with the richest verdure, with here and there a
palmetto-roofed cottage looking as primitive as need be."
ACT FIRST -- SCENE FIRST.
Correspondence that passed between the high contracting
powers on sea and on shore, at the fall of Alvarado.
Commander Hunter to Lieutenant Marin
U. S. Steamer Scourge
Alvarado, March 31st, 1847
Sir: the surrender of the city must be made in thirty minutes
from this time, and must be unconditional. If, at the expiration of that time, they do not
agree to our terms, I'll open upon the town and order the troops to advance. Very
respectfully, &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Com'g.
To. Lieut. M. C. Marin, U. S. N.
at the Government House, Alvarado.
Commander Hunter to the Spanish Consul
U. S. Steamer Scourge
Alvarado, March 31st, 1847
Sir: I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your letter
of this date; and cordially answer your solicitations. All under your national flag, and
subjects of her Catholic Majesty of Spain, shall meet with the due considerations of
friendship, and of the friendly power which you represent. I have the honor, &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Lt. Com'g.
To Senor Don Francisco Sanchez,
Vice Consul H. C. M. of Spain, at Alvarado
Commander Hunter to Passed Midshipman Temple
U. S. Steamer Scourge Alvarado,
March 31st, 1847
Sir: You will take charge of the forts in and about the city of
Alvarado, and retain the command there until relieved by some superior officer. I am, Sir,
&c.,
Chas. G. Hunter, Lt. Com'g.
To Wm. G. Temple, Passed Midshipman,
on board U. S. Steamer Scourge.
The Demand for the Surrender of Flacotalpam
U. S. Steamer Scourge
Off Flacotalpam, March 31st, 1847
Sirs: In order to avoid unnecessary bloodshed, and in accordance
with the spirit and feeling of civilized nations, I demand, in the name of United States
of America, the entire and unconditional surrender of the city of Flacotalpam. I have the
honor, &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Lt. Com'g.
To the President and Ayuntamento
of the City of Flacotalpam.
Commander Hunter to Passed Midshipman Pringle
U. S. Steamer Scourge
April 1, 1847
Sir: You will proceed on board and take charge of the prize
schooner now lying near this vessel. At high water you'll get her off and take her down to
Alvarado, and report to me on your arrival., I am &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Lt. Com'g.
To J. J. Pringle, Passed Midshipman
on board the U. S. Steamer Scourge.
Commander Hunter to Commodore Perry
U. S. Steamer Scourge
April 3, 1847
Sir: Enclosed I send you a letter from the Alcalde of
Flacotalpam, enclosing a communication from a Governor of Cosamaloapam relative to seven
men and one midshipman, prisoners whose release I demanded while at Flacotalpam. I have
the honor, &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Lt. Com'g.
To Commodore M. C. Perry,
Commanding Gulf Squadron.
Acting-Master Bankhead to Commander Harris
U. S. Steamer Scourge
Alvarado, March 31, 1847
Sir: Agreeably to your orders I went on board of the Mexican
schooner Matilda, and finding it impossible to get her off, owing to her having been
scuttled previously, I destroyed everything I could get at, and then set fire to her. She
was loaded with munitions of war -- principally powder, canister shot, and Congreve
rockets. Ascertain before I left her that the fire had made such progress that it was
impossible to extinguish it, I proceeded up the river after the steamer. Respectfully your
obedient servant,
J. P. Bankhead, Acting Master
Lt. Com. Hunter U. S. Steamer Scourge.
Commander Hunter to Commodore Perry
U. S. Steamer Scourge
April 2d, 1847
Sir: I have the honor to report that on the afternoon of the 30th
ultimo, at about 5 o'clock, I arrived off the bar of this river; that I immediately opened
upon the forts with round shot and shell, but finding a heavy surf on the bar, and seeing
indications of a Norther, I stood off and on during the night. In the morning I again
opened on the forts, when I discovered a white flag on the beach, and, shortly thereafter,
the Captain of the port and a pilot came off with a flag of truce, offering a surrender of
the place, and informing me that the Mexican troops (to the number of three or four
hundred) had, after our attack, evacuated the forts and the city the night previous,
having fired all the government vessels, spiked a portion of the guns and buried others in
the sand. With a view of preventing any further destruction of public property, or a
return of the Mexicans before your arrival, and for the purpose of securing an
unobstructed entrance for the squadron, I came in, anchored off the town, received their
surrender, (a copy of which I herewith enclose,) hoisted the American flag under a salute
of twenty-one guns, and then, hearing that the garrison of the place was hastening up the
river with two or three vessels loaded with arms, ammunition, and other public property, I
left Passed-Midshipman Temple, with five men, in command of the place, and stood up the
river after them. On the way up I succeeded in capturing four schooners; one that I
burned, as I could not get her off; another I left behind as worthless; the third I towed
down, and the fourth is now coming down under the command of Passed Midshipman Pringle. At
2 o'clock in the morning I anchored off Flacotalpam, a city of about 7,000 inhabitants,
sent Lieutenant Marin ashore to the alcalde, assembled the junta, and demanded an entire
and unconditional surrender within half an hour. My demands were at once complied with,
and I herewith transmitted copy of their surrender. I am, &c.,
C. G. Hunter, Lt. Comd'g.
To Commodore M. C. Perry
Commander-in-Chief of the Gulf Squadron.
Passed-Midshipman Temple to Commander Hunter
Alvarado, April 1st, 1847.
Sir: I have the honor to report, that in obedience to your order
of yesterday, I have this afternoon delivered over the command of the forts in and about
this place, to Commodore Perry. I am sir, &c.,
Wm. G. Temple, Passed Midshipman.
To Lieut. C. G. Hunter, Com.
U. S. Steamer Scourge.
Passed Midshipman Pringle to Commander Hunter
Alvarado, April 2d, 1847.
Sir: I have the honor to report, that agreeably to your order of
the 1st instant, I went with a prize crew on board this schooner captured by our boats on
the evening of the 31st March -- took possession of her -- called her out of the Creek in
which she was lying, and this morning brought her down the river, and had anchored her off
the town, near the Scourge. Respectfully yours,
J. J. Pringle, Passed Midshipman
To Lieut. C. G. Hunter, Commanding
U.S.S. Scourge, Alvarado.
ACT SECOND -- SCENE SECOND.
The Trial, Defense, and Reprimand
of Lieut. Hunter
before a Naval Court Martial
Charges and Specifications. Charges
and specifications preferred by Commodore M. C. Perry, Commander-in-Chief of the United
States Naval Forces in the Gulf of Mexico, against Lieut. Charles G. Hunter, United States
Navy, late commanding the U. S. Steamer Scourge.
Charge First -- Treating with contempt his
superior, being in the execution of his office.
Specification First -- in that he, this said
Lieutenant Charles G. Hunter, U. S. Navy, did on the 31st day of March, 1847, being then
in the command of the U. S. Steamer Scourge, enter the port of Alvarado, and did there
arrogate to himself, (the said Lieut. Charles G. Hunter,) the authority and power, that
are vested only in the Commander-in-Chief, but entering into stipulations for, and
receiving the surrender of Alvarado and its dependencies.
Specification Second -- In that the said Lieut.
Charles G. Hunter, U. S. Navy, did on the 31st day of March, 1847, with the U. S. Steamer
Scourge under his command, proceed from Alvarado to the town of Flacotalpam, without any
orders or authority, and there demand the surrender of the said town of Flacotalpam. And
enter into and sign articles of capitulation, although aware of the immediate approach of
the Commander-in-Chief, to whom alone such powers are confided -- thus treating with
contempt the authority of his superior, being in execution of his office.
Specification Third -- In that the said Lieut.
Charles G. Hunter, U. S. Navy, did, on the 31st day of March, 1847, in proceeding from
Alvarado to Flacotalpam, capture four schooners, one of which he set on fire and burnt,
and another he abandoned, thus substituting his own will for the discretion of the
Commander-in-Chief, who was within a few hours' reach of communication, and treating with
contempt the authority of his superior; all of which is in violation of the laws of United
States, as contained in "an Act for the better government of the Navy of United
States, approved April 23d, 1800."
Charge Second -- Disobedience of orders.
Specification First -- In that he, the said Lieut.
Charles G. Hunter, U. S. Navy, having been ordered to report to Captain Samuel L. Breese,
and to assist in blockading the port of Alvarado, did, in disobedience or disregarded said
orders, enter the harbor and take possession of the town of Alvarado.
Specification Second -- In that he, the said
Lieutenant Charles G. Hunter, U. S. Navy, having been ordered on the evening of the 1st
April, to report himself in person to the Commander-in-Chief, at his quarters in the town
of Alvarado, at 10 o'clock, A. M., of the following morning, did disobey said order; all
of which is in violation on the laws of United States, as contained in "an Act for
the better government of the Navy of United States, approved April 23d, 1800."
M. C. Perry
Commanding Home Squadron.
Click here
for Lt. Hunter's Defense
and the Results of the Court Martial
The Broad
Pennant. A Cruise in the United States Flag Ship of the Gulf Squadron, During the
Mexican Difficulties Together With Sketches of the Mexican War. Rev.
Fitch W. Taylor, A. M., USN. Leavitt, Tron & Co., New York. 1848.
|